Settle or Sue: A High School Business Law Lab on Procedural Law and Dispute Resolution
Most students think a lawsuit is a form you fill in and a judge who decides. Settle or Sue shows them what really happens, by putting them inside one.
The story
Your students work the window at Smoke & Mirrors, a busy barbecue food truck in San Antonio. When the lease on the truck’s corner lot ends, the landlord keeps the entire $6,000 security deposit for “grease damage.” The owner, Luis, says the stain was there when they arrived. He fires off a text, “Then I’ll see you in court,” and files a lawsuit that same afternoon, without rereading the lease he signed.
What follows is eleven weeks of envelopes: a lawyer’s answer, a counterclaim, written questions under oath, and a deposition notice with the student’s own name on it. Answering those questions, students find the one piece of evidence nobody else noticed: their own launch-day Instagram post, dated and geotagged, with the stain clearly visible.
Then a paralegal named Dana walks in, opens the lease to clause 13, and draws four doors on a whiteboard. Students learn that court was only one way out, and not the best one. They sit at a mediation table and move the landlord from nothing to $3,500. They run the numbers on settling versus suing. They watch the hearing, won with the evidence they found. And then they discover the lesson that sticks: even when Luis wins in court, he ends up with less money, later, than if he’d mediated first.
What students learn
- Alternative dispute resolution: negotiation, mediation, arbitration and litigation, with the real cost, time and control of each
- The steps of a civil lawsuit: complaint, answer, discovery, pretrial hearing, trial, judgment and appeal
- Discovery methods: interrogatories, requests for admission, depositions, and physical or mental examinations
- The people in a courtroom: plaintiff, defendant, attorney, judge, petit and grand juries, paralegal, court reporter and prosecutor
- Civil vs. criminal cases: the steps of a criminal case (arrest, arraignment, bail, voir dire, verdict, sentence), told through a bounced cheque
- Burden of proof: preponderance of the evidence vs. beyond a reasonable doubt, made visible on a live evidence scale
- The statute of limitations, and why missing the deadline closes every door
- How to analyse a court case: the kind of case, the issue, the facts, the rule and the decision
What makes it work in the classroom
- Students learn by living it. They meet each legal step when it lands on the counter, then a mentor names what they’ve already experienced.
- Interactive, not passive. Calculators, drag-and-drop timelines, a branching mediation where every choice moves the number, and a courtroom transcript with pause-and-decide moments. Students are never more than a few minutes from doing something.
- The math matters. Students work out what a day at the truck earns, what the lawsuit really costs, and whether a sure $3,500 beats a 70% chance at more. Settle-or-sue thinking that transfers to real life.
- Low prep, auto-graded. Students work individually, at their own pace. Activities grade themselves with instant feedback; the teacher reviews only a few short written answers.
- Built for reluctant readers. Short, story-driven slides written for grades 9 to 10, with every legal term defined in plain words the first time it appears.
- Ends with test-ready vocabulary. A term-by-term review tied to the story, a state-test-style vocabulary test, and a short analysis of the hearing.
At a glance
- Grades: 9-12, Business Law and CTE business courses
- Time: about three 50-minute class periods (fast classes can finish in two)
- Format: individual, self-paced, online
- Includes: story slide decks, interactive activities, an auto-graded vocabulary test, a teacher-reviewed reflection, and a student survey
- Standards: aligned to Utah Business Law Strand 3 (Procedural Law) and Texas TEKS 130.130 (c)(3) and (c)(8), and fits the procedural-law unit of any state’s business law course
Who it’s for
Business law, legal studies and CTE business teachers who want students to understand how disputes actually get resolved, not just memorise the vocabulary. It works as a stand-alone supplement after your own textbook unit on court procedure or dispute resolution, with no other labs required.
When someone takes your money, do you fight or deal? By the end of this lab, your students will know how to decide.